Riemann showed that the number N(t) of zeros ρ of the ζ function with 0 < Im(ρ) < t is closely approximated by the expression
- N(t) ≈ (t/2π) [log(t/2π) − 1] .
In a previous post I give a heuristic argument that this expression can be augmented by a "periodic term"
- ΔN(t) = − (2π)−1∑q (k√q)−1sin(t log q) ,
where the sum ranges over all primes and their powers, q = pk. This term introduces a unit step in N(t) at each occurrence of a zero in ζ(s) on top of Riemann's secular term. Reproduced below are a small number of tests to see how well this expression works.
N(t) in the range [10:50], showing unit steps at the first 10 zeros of ζ(s), computed from a formula depending on the first 2,091 primes.
The "frequencies" in the expression for ΔN(t) are logarithms of primes, and so the sum must be pushed out to quite a large number to achieve a high resolution in t. But this is not really a major problem since the zeros are generally well spaced, and the local density is also logarithmic,
- N′(t) ≈ (2π)-1log(t/2π) .
Low resolution in t appears to be quite satisfactory in the range I've checked (t < 7,000).
For tests presented here, I used the first 2,091 primes (up to 18,251), and 71 prime powers less than that maximum. Since log(18,251) = 9.8, the resolution in t is around 0.1. I computed N(t) in four intervals: [10:50], [200:220], [1000:1020], and [6990:7010] at a spacing of 0.2 for the first case and 0.1 for the remaining three. A small adjustment of β = 0.87 was added to N(t to get the correct integer count of the zeros. That is, any residual secular term appears to be quite small.
The n-th zero of ζ(s) is estimated (by interpolation) from where the computed N(t) crosses the half-integer value n-0.5. Within the four ranges tested, there are 10, 11, 16, and 23 zeros, and comparison with the known values of αn = Im(sn) yields r.m.s. differences 0.0043, 0.0112, 0.0151, and 0.0284, respectively; i.e., the agreement degrades toward larger values of t. This may be due to crowding of the zeros at larger t (see last figure below). Note in particular the relatively large error in estimating the two close zero near 7005. Tests including a larger number of primes are clearly needed to improve resolution and separate the zeros more cleanly.
N(t) in the range [200:220], showing unit steps at the 11 zeros of ζ(s) in this range, as computed from a formula depending on the first 2,091 primes.
N(t) in the range [1000:1020], showing unit steps at the 16 zeros of ζ(s) in this range, as computed from a formula depending on the first 2,091 primes.
N(t) in the range [6990:7010], showing unit steps at the 23 zeros of ζ(s) in this range, as computed from a formula depending on the first 2,091 primes.
===================================
αn αn
n-0.5 (est.) (exact) Δαn
-----------------------------------
0.5 14.133 14.135 -0.002
1.5 21.028 21.022 0.006
2.5 25.013 25.011 0.002
3.5 30.432 30.425 0.008
4.5 32.932 32.935 -0.003
5.5 37.587 37.586 0.001
6.5 40.918 40.919 -0.001
7.5 43.327 43.327 0.000
8.5 48.013 48.005 0.007
9.5 49.769 49.774 -0.004
-----------------------------------
79.5 201.267 201.265 0.002
80.5 202.509 202.494 0.015
81.5 204.175 204.190 -0.015
82.5 205.398 205.395 0.003
83.5 207.921 207.906 0.015
84.5 209.570 209.577 -0.006
85.5 211.709 211.691 0.018
86.5 213.334 213.348 -0.014
87.5 214.546 214.547 -0.001
88.5 216.175 216.170 0.005
89.5 219.065 219.068 -0.003
-----------------------------------
649.5 1001.354 1001.349 0.004
650.5 1002.408 1002.404 0.004
651.5 1003.271 1003.268 0.003
652.5 1004.679 1004.675 0.003
653.5 1005.534 1005.543 -0.009
654.5 1008.002 1008.007 -0.004
655.5 1008.812 1008.796 0.016
656.5 1009.791 1009.807 -0.016
657.5 1010.582 1010.570 0.012
658.5 1012.413 1012.410 0.003
659.5 1013.095 1013.059 0.036
660.5 1014.667 1014.690 -0.023
661.5 1016.052 1016.060 -0.009
662.5 1017.262 1017.266 -0.005
663.5 1018.614 1018.606 0.008
664.5 1019.940 1019.912 0.028
-----------------------------------
6691.5 6990.087 6990.113 -0.026
6692.5 6990.678 6990.679 -0.001
6693.5 6991.968 6991.940 0.028
6694.5 6992.255 6992.275 -0.021
6695.5 6993.166 6993.159 0.007
6696.5 6994.111 6994.110 0.001
6697.5 6995.037 6995.039 -0.003
6698.5 6995.824 6995.819 0.005
6699.5 6996.907 6996.887 0.020
6700.5 6997.790 6997.809 -0.018
6701.5 6998.503 6998.499 0.004
6702.5 6999.705 6999.683 0.022
6703.5 7000.707 7000.718 -0.010
6704.5 7001.853 7001.856 -0.003
6705.5 7002.380 7002.353 0.027
6706.5 7002.669 7002.692 -0.022
6707.5 7004.065 7004.044 0.021
6708.5 7004.988 7005.063 -0.075
6709.5 7005.175 7005.101 0.074
6710.5 7006.729 7006.740 -0.011
6711.5 7008.105 7008.115 -0.009
6712.5 7008.830 7008.817 0.012
6713.5 7009.406 7009.368 0.038
-----------------------------------