Sunday, March 10, 2013

Heuristic Argument for ΔN(t)

J(x) is the function that "counts" primes and their powers, and can be written as a sum involving π(x) and ultimately in terms of Heavyside step functions,

  • J(x) = ∑k π(x1/k)/k = ∑p,k U(x−pk)/k.

Riemann's basic result is that J(x) can be expressed in terms of Li(x) and the non-trivial zeros ρ of the ζ function,

  • J(x) = Li(x) − ∑ρ Li(xρ) + ε(x),

where ε(x) is a very small correction term.

If ρ lies on the critical line (the Riemann hypothesis), then

  • Li(xρ) = Li(x½+iα) ≈ √x eiα log x/(½+iα)log x .

Since the zeros of the ζ function occur as conjugate pairs, the imaginary part of the sum disappears, and only consider the real part needs to be considered,

  • Re[ Li(x½+iα) ] ≈ √x sin(α log x)/α log x

where α is assumed to be large enough to ignore the 1/2 term in the denominator. This approximation makes it clear why Riemann refers to the sum of Li(xρ) as the periodic part of J(x).

Likewise, N(t) is the function that "counts" the zeros of the ζ function,

  • N(t) = ∑α>0 U(t−α) ≈ (t/2π) [log(t/2π) − 1] .

There is a heuristic argument that N(t) must also have a periodic part, motivated by taking t = α and y = log x to be conjugate variables in the above approximation for Li(xρ). We differentiate J(x) with respect to y (not x!) and retain only the dominant term (derivatives of sines), to get

  • ∑p,k δ(y−log pk)/k ≈ x/log x − ∑α √x cos(αy)/log x .

Multiply through by log x/√x so that x is evaluated at prime powers:

  • ∑q (k√q)−1log q δ(y−log q) ≈ ey/2 − ∑α cos(αy) .

where q = pk ranges over all primes and their powers.

Performing a Fourier transform on this expression swaps δ and cosine functions, yielding

  • ∑q (k√q)−1log q cos(t log q) ≈ h(t) − 2π∑α δ(t−α) .

Integration with respect to t yields the desired expression for N(t):

  • N(t) = ∑α U(t−α) ≈ H(t) − (2π)−1∑q (k√q)−1sin(t log q) .

The sum on the left-hand side may be interpreted as the "periodic term" ΔN(t), so H(t) should be very nearly the known secular term given above; that is

  • N(t) ≈ (t/2π) [log(t/2π) − 1] − (2π)−1∑q (k√q)−1sin(t log q) + β(t) ,

where β(t) is a correction term undetermined by this argument.

The next step is to evaluate this expression numerically.

No comments:

Post a Comment